A Case of Mistaken Identity: Can You Spot the False Oil Positives?

Posted Fri, 05/31/2019 - 12:39
An aerial view of varying shades of oil being collected in pollution boom.
Aerial view of emulsified oil at the Bayou Perot well blowout changing to dark oil as it degasses and dewaters. Image credit: Gary Shigenaka/NOAA.

When asked what oil looks like, most people would probably describe it similar to molasses — black, and somewhat viscous in appearance. But did you know, crude oils can come in a range of colors? From black to red to yellow, oil can appear in a number of different colors and consistencies. This can make it especially hard to find and identify oil from the air.

In the image above, a range of colors can be seen at the site of a well leak in Bayou Perot, Louisiana. The oil that is closest to the source — visibly spraying out of the well — is yellowish. As the oil collects in the pollution boom around it, it gets thicker and becomes orange. And the thickest oil, collected to the far end of the boom, is black.

While different types of oils can vary in appearance, oil slick appearance is also affected by weather conditions and how long the oil has been out on the water. Though images of a heavy continuous coating of oil on the sea or shoreline might be the first thing that comes to mind when you think of an oil spill, that same spill could look quite different after a few hours or days.

Over time, oil can become patchy, it can emulsify, or become mixed with water. The color and consistency can change as the oil encounters other materials in the water, or simply the exposure to air. Even close to the source of the spill the colors can be quite variable depending on the thickness of the oil.

During a spill response, trained aerial overflight experts serve as the eyes for the command post of spill responders. They report critical information like location, size, shape, color, and orientation of an oil slick.

Because oil comes in such a wide variety of colors, it can easily be mistaken for something else — and vice versa. When searching by air, or even by satellite, responders can come across false positives for oil.

A light brown substance in a body of water near a boat.
Closeup of algae bloom in marina near Whidbey Island, Washington.

In this photo from a marina in Washington (right), this naturally occurring algae looks a lot like a reddish brown oil. When viewed from the air, algal blooms, boat wakes, seagrass, and many other things can look like oil. Important clues, such as if heavy pollen or algal blooms are common in the area, help aerial observers make the determination between false positives and the real deal. If the determination cannot be made by aerial observation, further investigation may be needed to properly identify the anomaly.

In the slideshow below, put your eyes, and your knowledge, to the test. Many of the images look very similar to oil — so much so that they required a second look to confirm their identity. Can you spot the false positives?

How did you do? Was there a particular false positive you struggled to identify? Share your thoughts and results in the comments below. You can also tweet us @NOAACleanCoasts or comment on Facebook @noaaresponserestoration.

 

To learn more and for training resources, visit the links below:

Image credit: Scripps Institution of Oceanography.
A huge anchovy school offshore of La Jolla, California. A dense school of fish along the shoreline can easily be mistaken for dark oil. Note that there is no sheen present and closer examination may show that the color is not on the surface, but subsurface. Image credit: Scripps Institution of Oceanography.
Image credit: U.S. Coast Guard.
Dark oil on the Mississippi River following the M/V Westchester oil spill. Dark oil is usually pretty obvious. It retains its original color, which may vary from black to different shades of brown. Image credit: U.S. Coast Guard.
Image credit: Alan Mearns/NOAA.
Mussel bed in Prince William Sound, Alaska. Mussels can form large dark beds in the lower to mid intertidal zone, typically in wave-washed areas. On a calm day, they can be mistaken for submerged or stranded oil. Image credit: Alan Mearns/NOAA.
Image credit: K. Reece/W. Jones/W. Vogelbein.
Algal bloom in Chesapeake Bay. Algal blooms are among the more difficult false positives. Depending on the algae, they form a wide range of colors and may appear at the surface or just below. Image credit: K. Reece/W. Jones/W. Vogelbein.
Image credit: NOAA.
Emulsified oil in windrows during Deepwater Horizon. Windrows concentrate oil into bands, whether it's sheen or dark or emulsified oil. Image credit: NOAA.
Image credit: P. Alejandro Diaz and Ginny Velasquez.
Plankton blooms, sometimes referred to as red tides, are commonly reported as oil. Color may vary from reddish brown, red, orange, to even light pink. In all cases, the plankton are not just on the surface but in the upper water column, which gives an appearance of a cloud in the water and not a sheen or a slick on the surface. Image credit: P. Alejandro Diaz and Ginny Velasquez.
Image credit: Tom Roorda/USGS.
Sediment plume from the Elwha River in Washington. Sediment plumes can take on the reddish hue of emulsified oil. Image credit: Tom Roorda/USGS.
At times cloud shadows on water may have the appearance of oil. Inspect closely and check for sheens.
Image credit: Ruth Yender/NOAA.
Patches of oil rising to the surface from the sunken tanker Solar 1, Philippines. Sometimes oil from a submerged source rises to the surface as a series of discrete drops that spread out or "blossom" into patches at the surface. Image credit: Ruth Yender/NOAA.
Large accumulations of Jellyfish (spring/summer) are frequently mistaken for oil. If in doubt, inspect more closely at a lower altitude. Most oil spills will have a sheen around the edges, helping sort out the spills from the false positives.
Kelp beds are frequently mistaken for oil. Sometimes kelp bulbs may be misidentified as tarballs.
1 of 22

A Case of Mistaken Identity: Can You Spot the False Oil Positives?

Posted Fri, 05/31/2019 - 12:39

Mike Lynch

Fri, 05/31/2019 - 14:38

Over a decade ago we had a mystery oil spill near Tacoma. I got a tip from someone trying to be helpful who said a relative flying out of SeaTac airport had seen a trail of black behind a ship days before the oil spill actually occurred. They assumed it was oil and gave a description of the ship. Looking at file aerial photos of the area led to the conclusion that what the person in the aircraft had seen was a surface layer of fresh water containing glacial flour (silt) from the Puyallup River being disrupted in the wake of the departing deep draft ship. The disruption/displacement of surface lens of silty fresher water by the moving ship allowed the darker color of the saltier, clearer water beneath to show through.

Add new comment

We appreciate your interest and welcome your feedback to our posts. Please provide comments that are relevant to the topic. Comments will be reviewed before publishing.

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
If you want notification when others comment on this topic, please provide your email. We will not use the email for anything other than notifying you of blog activity, and it will not be displayed with your comment. Learn more in our privacy policy and the Privacy Act Statement.
CAPTCHA
Please help us prevent automated spam submissions:
6 + 2 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.